header 1
header 2
header 3

Message Forum - GENERAL

Welcome to the Bethesda Chevy Chase High School Message Forum.

The message forum is an ongoing dialogue between classmates. There are no items, topics, subtopics, etc.

Forums work when people participate - so don't be bashful! Click the "Post Message" button to add your entry to the forum.


 
go to bottom 
  Post Message
  
    Prior Page
 Page  
Next Page      

08/25/25 03:44 PM #18396    

 

Jay Shackford

Thanks Joan.  I enjoyed your post as well.  Happy Labor Day everyone.  


08/26/25 06:49 AM #18397    

 

Jack Mallory

Nicely done, Jay. 

*******
I see the FF is calling for a year in prison for manifesting what the Supreme Court has defined as free speech--burning the American flag. 
“If you burn a flag, you get one year in jail, no early exits, no nothing." In the past Bone Spurs has suggested loss of citizenship as a punishment for flag burning.

 

The flag is nothing more than a piece of multi-colored cloth. UNLESS it is a symbol of American freedoms. My oath of enlistment, Trump's oath of office, state that we will defend the Constitution of the United States, not the flag. Threats of imprisonment for burning a symbol of Constitutionally protected speech are clearly a contradiction he cannot get his little fingers, or brain, to grasp.

Trump clearly fails to understand this, or much else about the Constitution, as he imposes armed military intervention in our capitol and threatens other cities. Who remembers what our Colonial ancestors were protesting when the British responded with the Boston Massacre? Yes, military occupation to suppress free speech.

Molly Ivens put it nicely:


08/26/25 07:31 AM #18398    

 

Joanie Bender (Grosfeld)

Jack, that was a fabulous quote by Molly Ivens. Thank you for posting that.

Jay, I just had a chance to read your wonderful post. Thanks so much. It sounded like an amazing trip through the Alps. Your speculation about Melania possibly being introduced to Trump is quite possible. 

I was so heartened to hear our Governor Wes Moore say no to Trump sending the National Guard to Baltimore...Then we have, Governor Pritzker who also let Trump have it saying that he was not welcome to send the National Guard to Chicago.  I loved his spunk. As we can see, Trump is targeting Blue cities. I think that sometimes Trump backs off from those who stand up to him as bullies are really cowards. We need more to say no, like Lisa Cook, from the Federal Reserve Board, who Trump has no authoritiy to fire. She is the first black person appointed to the Board by Biden and her term will be up in 2038. She said she would not resign but continuing the work she is doing. Love, Joanie

Here is the Governor's speech:  

https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/illinois-governor-jb-pritkzer-speech-news-conference-full-text-trump/


08/27/25 10:53 AM #18399    

 

Jay Shackford

Never Forget Katrina

 

Today is the 20th anniversary of Katrina — the most deadly and destructive natural disaster of our time.  If you get a chance, watch the new Netflix three-part series on Katrina released today.  Moving, powerful, and brutally honest on what happened and why and what has or hasn’t happened since then to rebuild one of America’s great and most vibrant cities— one unmatched when it comes to food, music, culture, and soul.      

 

Katrina is one of those events of our lifetimes — along with the JFK assassination, the killings of MLK and Robert Kennedy, Vietnam and Kent State, the lunar moon landing, 9/11, the invasion of Iraq, the September 2008 financial meltdown, and, most recently, the January 6th insurrection at the U.S. Capitol — when we can remember exactly where we were and what we were doing when we first learned about the tragedy unfolding.  

 

The question today is whether we are better prepared for the next Katrina?  Sadly, I don’t think so.  

 

During Trump’s first seven months, he has cut FEMA’s budget and workforce by 2,000 (including the guys and gals who fly planes into the middle of hurricanes to track them).  Trump has withheld federal aid to assist Los Angeles rebuild from last year’s deadly wildfires. 

 

On Tuesday, the day before Katrina’s anniversary, FEMA suspended around 30 employees after those workers wrote to Congress warning that the Trump Administration had gutted the nation’s ability to handle hurricanes, floods, and other extreme weather disasters, according to the New York Times.

 

Of the 182 FEMA employees who signed the letter to Congress, 36 attached their names, while the rest withheld their identities for fear of retaliation.  

 

Those who used their names received emails on Tuesday night saying they had been placed on paid administrative leave “effective immediately, and continuing until further notice.” 

 

When the NYT asked FEMA to comment, it refused to respond.  

 


08/28/25 03:50 AM #18400    

 

Joan Ruggles (Young)

Here's my favorite recent headline that isn't from The Onion:

"Trump Forgets He Hates Taylor Swift When He’s Told She’s Getting Married"

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/donald-trump-taylor-swift-travis-kelce-engagement-1235416038/

Second favorite:

"National Guard troops deployed in D.C. add sanitation, landscaping duties"

https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2025/08/27/dc-national-guard-trash-removal-trump-takeover/?utm_campaign=wp_evening_edition&utm_medium=email&utm_source=newsletter&carta-url=https%3A%2F%2Fs2.washingtonpost.com%2Fcar-ln-tr%2F4468157%2F68af71d70a9d076bef803e76%2F596b6c569bbc0f403f909f18%2F21%2F47%2F68af71d70a9d076bef803e76

And OK here's a trick question. Is this headline from The New York Times or from The Onion:

"FDA Warns Against Eating Potentially Radioactive Shrimp Sold At Walmart"

what about this one?:

"Recall of Frozen Shrimp Expands After Radioactive Contamination Warning"

First one is The Onion. Second one from NYT. Satire and reality have merged!  


08/29/25 10:16 AM #18401    

 

Jay Shackford

The Sycophancy Must Be Televised

By Susan Glasser/The New Yorker

August 28, 2025

When Donald Trump began to speak on Tuesday, during what would become the longest televised Cabinet meeting ever, he did not exactly advertise his plans to make history. There was a lot of the usual Trump palaver about how windmills are “ruining our country” and about the transformative power of his tariffs, which, he insisted, will completely revitalize the American economy. “It’s going to happen like magic,” he vowed. “It’s going to happen without question.” Standard stuff, at least for Trump 2.0, with the President’s top advisers gazing adoringly as Trump vamps for the cameras.

But, in hindsight, the warning signs were there. For starters, it was more than seventeen minutes before anyone else said a word at the meeting, and, even then, the speaker—Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent—only managed a “Yes, sir” before Trump resumed speaking. No one else said anything of substance after that for another fifteen minutes, at which point the President called not on a member of the Cabinet but on Iris Tao, a reporter for the Epoch Times, a far-right news organization linked to an exiled Chinese opposition movement. “I heard you were very savagely mugged in the city,” he said, inviting her to recount the episode. She did so, recalling a terrifying incident of a man in a ski mask striking her in the face with the butt of a gun, and concluded with profuse thanks to the President for his decision to send in federal troops to fight crime in Washington. “Thank you for now making D.C. safer,” Tao said. “For us, for our families, for my parents, on behalf of my parents, and now my baby on the way. Thank you so much.” This is what passes for journalism these days at the White House, now that Trump’s staff has taken control of the formerly independent press rotation and started deciding on its own which news organizations get access to the President. The Kremlin press pool could not have played the moment any better.

As for Trump, his performance, too, seemed right out of the Kremlin playbook. As the meeting dragged on, I remembered Vladimir Putin’s tradition of a marathon annual press conference, in which he holds forth on matters as varied as street cleaning and the perfidy of the West. Putin’s all-time record for one of these appearances, set in 2008, was four hours and forty minutes, so I guess there is still something for Trump to aspire to. In the end, Tuesday’s Cabinet meeting clocked in at three hours and seventeen minutes, which, if it did not beat Putin, was still significantly longer than “The Godfather,” as was quickly noted. (Can you imagine the Rotten Tomatoes score if audiences were actually forced to watch Tuesday’s meeting in full?) The first Cabinet member to be called on, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., did not get to speak until more than forty-eight minutes had elapsed. The first questions to the press did not come until nearly two and a half hours in.

There is a strong argument to be made for not wasting time with what followed. We already know that this live-streaming President is addicted to his own show; of course, he’ll let it run as long as possible. As for the rest, it’s hardly a revelation that Trump’s fellow cast members are so desperate for a bit of his airtime—and approbation—that they’ll say anything to get it. Besides, it’s been a week with so many other truly extraordinary developments emanating from the Trump Administration, “a Watergate every day,” as the author Garrett Graff put it. Does another Trump talkfest actually rate?

An incomplete catalogue of events since my last Letter from Trump’s Washington would include the White House’s attempt to fire Lisa Cook, a governor of the independent Federal Reserve; the attempted ouster of Trump’s new head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and subsequent resignations of several senior officials in protest of Kennedy’s anti-vaccine policies; the President’s threat to expand his militarization of domestic policing from Washington to other Democratic-run cities such as Baltimore and Chicago; a federal takeover of Union Station; a new executive order purporting to ban flag-burning in defiance of Supreme Court decisions ruling that it is constitutionally protected free speech; Friday-evening purges of senior officials in the intelligence community who contradicted the Administration’s propaganda; and the President personally demanding the prosecution of his former friend Chris Christie after Christie said something he did not like on television. And that’s the partial list.

With so many truly existential threats to the democracy unfolding during what is supposed to be the final vacation week before the post-Labor Day rush, it seems almost wrong to get worked up watching a hundred and ninety-seven minutes of Trump and his team of “butt-snorkelers,” as the retired Army General Ben Hodges memorably called them.

Nonetheless, dear reader, I watched. And, I would argue, it was worth every excruciating minute.

Trump, like any narcissist who is handed a microphone before an adoring audience, can’t help but reveal. One thing this Cabinet meeting and other recent appearances have shown is a President who is openly riffing as never before about his unchecked reign. “Not that I don’t have the right to do anything I want to do,” he explained at one point, while elaborating on his plans to expand troop deployments. “I’m the President of the United States. If I think our country is in danger, and it is in danger in these cities, I can do it.” He also commented, as he had a day earlier, on critics who say he’s acting like a dictator with his police power grab. “Most people say, ‘If you call him a dictator then . . . if he stops crime, he can be whatever he wants,’ ” Trump said, before adding, “I’m not a dictator, by the way.”

Aside from his almost palpable delight that so many people have finally figured out he’s a world-class strongman, Trump could not restrain himself from admitting what lies behind the performative anti-crime spree that he’s launched in Washington—the prospect of a winning issue in next year’s midterm elections. “I think crime is going to be a big thing,” he said, two hours and thirty-six minutes into the meeting. “And we are the party, the Republicans are the party that wants to stop crime. . . . It’s going to be a big, big subject for the midterms. And I think the Republicans are going to do really well.”

As is often the case, though, Trump’s biggest reveal is what he shows about those around him; he is a mirror, and not a flattering one, for other people’s souls. In that category, few on Tuesday could top the Secretary of Labor, Lori Chavez-DeRemer, who invited Trump to come see his own “big, beautiful face” mounted on a huge, Putin-style banner flying on the outside of her department’s headquarters. “You are really the transformational President of the American worker,” she told him. Brooke Rollins, the Secretary of Agriculture, offered some stiff competition, though, as she waxed poetic about Trump’s contribution to the history of the Republic. “I do believe we’re in a revolution,” she said. “1776 was the first one, 1863 or so with Abraham Lincoln was the second. This is the third, with Donald Trump leading the way. And we are saving America.”

Neither of them, however, could overshadow the day’s most riveting performance, by Steve Witkoff, the Trump golf partner turned global envoy. Witkoff, a real-estate lawyer by training whose apprenticeship in diplomacy has so far produced neither peace in Gaza nor an end to the war in Ukraine, offered a rousing paean to the boss. “I just don’t think you get the proper credit for it all,” he said, which is just about the most perfect pitch to make to a man for whom no recognition will ever be sufficient. Witkoff, in addition to proving himself a champion among champions in sycophancy, also showed some real skill during his short speech in another Washington art—that of goalpost-shifting. It was just this month that he and Trump spoke of an imminent deal to end the conflict in Ukraine, which they hoped to seal by rolling out the red carpet for Putin in Alaska. Two weeks later, with no deal, no ceasefire, and no foreseeable prospects of even a follow-up meeting between Putin and Ukraine’s President, Volodymyr Zelensky, which Trump had said would happen right away, Witkoff slipped into his remarks a new deadline for progress: “before the end of this year.”

Not that it matters. Witkoff told Trump that he already should go down in history as the greatest of all peacemakers. “There’s only one thing I wish for,” he said, “that the Nobel Committee finally gets its act together and realizes that you are the single finest candidate” ever for a Nobel Peace Prize. “Your success is game-changing out in the world today, and I hope everybody one day wakes up and realizes that,” he concluded, a finale that caused the entire Cabinet to break out in applause.

If only it had ended there. But there’s no editing Trump now. The show doesn’t end until he says it does. There’s an awful lot of tape to run until noon on January 20, 2028. ♦︎

Susan B. Glasser, a staff writer at The New Yorker, has a weekly column on life in Washington and is a host of the Political Scene podcast. She is also a co-author of “The Divider: Trump in the White House, 2017-2021.”


08/29/25 04:01 PM #18402    

 

Nora Skinker (Morton)

Interesting how very different we are! 
Susan Glasser's & my lenses couldn't be an odder couple! As Alice Roosevelt Longworth once said of her dad, "my father always wanted to be the corpse at every funeral, the bride at every wedding and the baby at every christening", I'm okay with a larger than life, attention gatherer as POTUS. I am also heartened by the open, very public cabinet meetings, the recognition given by the members to our hard working president (their boss), the candid discussions, relaxed atmosphere, the rapid progress already made, many of the goals stated & the common sense displayed in each quest for success. As I type this, I know for certain that gang members, criminals & illegal immigrants are at last being taken off our country's streets. A welcome feeling to know American citizens are being better protected. Of course there will be controversy, criticism & sheer politics at play but the path seems energized & hopeful.
   Glasser's bashing is merely political stirring of a pot that's boiling but not ready to be dished up. Though anticipation is high, time will tell. Til then, bash away Ms. Glasser & Jaybirds. Blah blah blah...


08/29/25 08:00 PM #18403    

 

Jack Mallory

"Butt-snorkelers." Oh. My. God. I love it. The military may not be able to win every useless war we send them to fight, but they provide us with a wonderful lexicon of language. 

I'll never be able to see a room full of the FF's cabinet members, advisors, and others who I might once have thought of as ass-kissers without now and forever thinking of them, even seeing them, as butt-snorkelers. Thank you, General, I salute you. 

********

I don't want to leave you stuck with that image of butt-snorkelers surrounding Trump, all looking for their chance to snork. 
 

This instead. A happy heron, cruising down the Contoocook behind the house, surrounded by the flowers of a New Hampshire summer. 


08/29/25 10:18 PM #18404    

 

Nora Skinker (Morton)

Would it be surprising to learn that cabinet members have been lauding their bosses for the last couple hundred years? Oh, that's right - we'll never know. 

 

 


08/30/25 06:21 AM #18405    

 

Jack Mallory

This morning HRC writes about the fate of those who fail the administration's butt-snorkeling requirements. A culture of butt-snorkeling endangers public health and safety when those who do their work based on science and the best interests of American tax payers lose their jobs because they refuse to participate.

It's a weak and hollow defense to say, "Well, that's happened for hundreds of years." Might even be considered butt-snorkeling!

August 29, 2025

Chaos continues at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), where President Donald J. Trump stepped in on Wednesday night to support Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. in his crusade to fire recently-confirmed Susan Monarez when she refused to rubber stamp his attack on vaccines.

With her ouster, three top scientists at the CDC resigned: Chief Medical Officer Debra Houry, National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases director Demetre Daskalakis, and National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases director Daniel Jernigan. “The CDC you knew is over,” Daskalakis said. “Unless someone takes radical action, there is nothing there that can be salvaged.”

On Thursday, CDC staff and supporters rallied outside the agency’s Atlanta headquarters, whose windows are still pocked with bullet holes from a terrorist who had become convinced the coronavirus vaccine had injured him, to honor the resigning leaders.

In place of Monarez, the White House has appointed as acting CDC director Jim O’Neill, a biotech investor close to billionaire Peter Thiel and a former speechwriter at the Department of Health and Human Services during the presidential term of George W. Bush. O’Neill has no training in either medicine or the science of infectious diseases. As Maanvi Singh and Robert Mackey of The Guardian reported, O’Neill supported the use of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine to treat covid despite no evidence that they worked. He also has embraced conspiracy theories about covid online.

The administration’s chaos extends to the Social Security Administration (SSA), where the administration forced Chief Data Officer Charles Borges to resign today. Borges had acted as a whistleblower for the agency when he identified serious data breaches that leave more than 300 million Americans at risk of identity theft and loss of benefits. In his resignation letter, Borges noted that he was leaving involuntarily after the administration had made it impossible to perform his duties legally and ethically and had caused him “serious attendant mental, physical, and emotional distress.”

In his letter, Borges noted that he has “served this Country for almost my entire adult life, first as an Active-Duty Naval Officer for over 22 years, and now as a civil servant. I was deployed during 9/11, decorated for valor in combat during Operation Iraqi Freedom, and graduated from US Naval Test Pilot School. As a civil servant, I have served as a Presidential Innovation Fellow, in the Centers for Disease Control during COVID, within [the Office of Management and Budget] on the Federal [Chief Information Officer] Data Team, and now serve as the SSA Chief Data Officer. I have served in each of these roles with honor and integrity.”

Makena Kelly and David Gilbert of Wired reported that less than 30 minutes after Borges’s resignation hit the in-boxes of SSA staff, it disappeared.

The removal of dedicated civil servants for trying to protect the public extends to the Environmental Protection Agency, where tonight the Trump administration fired at least seven employees for signing a letter criticizing the agency’s leadership for undermining “the EPA mission of protecting human health and the environment.” The firings are, Amudalat Ajasa of the Washington Post noted, “an escalation of the administration’s effort to clamp down on dissent within the federal bureaucracy.”

 


08/30/25 11:37 AM #18406    

 

Nora Skinker (Morton)

Hmm. Beats any argument that cabinet members of the past never shmoozed (ad nauseum?) the leaders who appointed them. Recalling LBJ's ego or studying Teddy Roosevelt, etal, I doubt that greatly. But, ok, Jack. Believe what you will. A good leader will 'command' respect in lieu of demanding it, but what is important to me is that he HAS respect from those who serve him & all of us. As for firing experts & life long government service folk, it's Trump's right "with due cause" &, as usual, will be sorted out in the courts. 


08/30/25 12:09 PM #18407    

 

Jay Shackford

Good golly, looks like Susan Glasser really touched a nerve with Nori who kind of reminds me of the wife of a good friend of mine who was a  self-made and very successful businessman before he died about 10 years ago from a heart attack.  Although very pretty and charming, she was a self-proclaimed, white, Christain Nationalist (pro life and all that) who married into a wealth and never had to work a day in their life to support her family. After her husband’s death, she and her kids were set up for life — although several of the kids have done very well on their own.  

 

 If you fall into this category, I guess you can afford to applaud Trump’s three-hour plus marathon cabinet meeting where “butt snorkling” was the name of the game and demonstrating blind support of a convicted felon and rapist despite mounting evidence that what we have here is a madman tyrant who would be willing push the nuclear button before giving up power or opening the door to the next deadly pandemic.   For me, it was a pathetic, disgraceful showing that sent me running to the bathroom a couple of times to puke.

 


08/30/25 03:14 PM #18408    

 

Jack Mallory

Jay, don't suppress your feelings. Tell us what you REALLY think!


08/30/25 07:40 PM #18409    

 

Jay Shackford

VAX Quack

 

By Maureen Dowd

New York Times/Opinion Columnist, reporting from Washington

 

I almost died of rubella when I was 3.

I was very weak and wouldn’t eat. My mother was frantic. The doctor prescribed mashed lima beans and I pulled through.

I still keep lima beans in the freezer.

It’s infuriating to see Bobby Kennedy Jr. be so benighted about vaccines, risking the health of all Americans. How can the most powerful country on earth sow the seeds to make people sick again with preventable, even once-eliminated diseases?

Between school shooters and R.F.K. Jr., children in America are vulnerable in ways they don’t have to be. Officials are endangering children instead of shielding them.

The boneheaded vaccine debate has inflamed the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which is reeling from mass layoffs and a deadly shooting by an anti-vaxxer at its headquarters.

 

Kennedy tried to fire the director, Susan Monarez, then called in President Trump to finish her off after she refused to go along with his dictum to back his advisers if they recommended restricting access to proven vaccines. Other officials quit, leaving the health agency in crisis, just as Winter Is Coming.

The administration put out the most restrictive policy yet on the new Covid vaccines, with more constraints likely, given that Kennedy has stacked the C.D.C. advisory committee with vaccine skeptics and outright anti-vaxxers.

When I was growing up, vaccines were the great American success story. It felt momentous when my father picked up my sister and me to go get polio shots.

My father helped guard F.D.R. at baseball games and other events. He saw F.D.R.’s braces, a result of polio, and saw the elaborate lengths the White House went to to camouflage the paralysis in the president’s lower body.

My family was grateful to be in the age of scientific achievement — from vaccine shots to moon shots. My mother would tell us harrowing tales of how her little sister, Mary, died in 1918 from the Spanish flu.

 

Trump and Kennedy are yanking us back to those dark times.

This month, Kennedy canceled nearly $500 million in grants and contracts for developing mRNA vaccines, the best chance against a future pandemic. That followed the cancellation of a $600 million contract to develop a vaccine for bird flu.

In March, as measles spread in Texas, Kennedy went on Fox News and promoted vitamin A and cod liver oil containing it as “dramatically” effective remedies. Some unvaccinated children took so much vitamin A, they showed signs of liver damage.

In 2019, Kennedy went to Samoa and claimed, falsely, that the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine had contributed to the deaths of two Samoan infants. That helped spark a measles outbreak that killed 83 there and infected 500 in Tonga.

On Wednesday, Kennedy was acting bizarre, saying he can tell as he walks past children if they are dealing with “mitochondrial challenges” or “inflammation.”

He has no medical degree. Can he mysteriously divine illnesses just by looking?

Our health secretary is a certified quack. But the president, who is letting Kennedy run wild, knows better. Trump got seriously ill from Covid and was saved by the doctors at Walter Reed, who gave him antibody treatments and remdesivir — not the remedy he once suggested people consider: bleach. His greatest triumph — and a stirring example of American scientific chops — was Operation Warp Speed, a push to develop a Covid vaccine in less than a year, saving many lives and springing us from our awful sequestration.

 

The Wall Street Journal reported Thursday that Trump told top donors that he wished he could brag about Operation Warp Speed. But he can’t offend MAHA (the ironically named Make America Healthy Again movement). He can’t push his greatest accomplishment because of the willful ignorance of some of his supporters.

Why does this notorious germaphobe play lickspittle to debunkers of science?

Disgusted with Monarez’s dismissal and the way Kennedy places ideology over science, four top officials resigned. One of them, Dr. Demetre Daskalakis, director of the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases, told The Journal and CNN’s Kaitlan Collins that Kennedy had not even bothered to be briefed by the center’s specialists on Covid and measles.

“Yes, he’s getting information from somewhere,” Daskalakis told Collins, “but that information is not coming from C.D.C. experts who really are the world’s experts in this area.”

Republicans failed miserably in not blocking Kennedy’s nomination. Senator Bill Cassidy, the gastroenterologist who cast the deciding vote on Trump’s snake-oil health secretary, said Wednesday that the chaos at C.D.C. would require oversight by Congress.

To which I reply: Physician, heal thyself. You were too craven to vote against someone you knew would decimate our health system because you wanted to hang onto your seat. You swapped the Hippocratic oath for the Hypocritic oath.

 

 

Asked about the C.D.C. meltdown Friday, Trump’s creepy consigliere Stephen Miller told reporters that Kennedy is “a crown jewel of this administration.”

Crown crank, more like.

 


08/31/25 06:20 AM #18410    

 

Jack Mallory

thanks again, Jay. Almost posted that myself, but was caught up in the great outdoors yesterday. 


But by Nori's logic, the fact that there have been science quacks throughout history justifies Kennedy's quackery. And his threats to the health of our children and others. Kennedy's perversions of science and medicine are clearly a form of butt-snorkeling, designed to keep him on the Trump train and in the public eye. His weak attempts to match his famous and more worthy kin?

AI gives us some interesting, Kennedy-like quacks from the past. I hope Trump's handlers know they're all dead, or he'll be touting and perhaps using using goat testicles and dyeing himself orange. Oh, wait . . . 

  • (1885–1942): A notorious charlatan who performed vasectomies on men and reimplanted goat testicles to cure impotence, earning him the nickname "Dr. Goat-Gland". 
  • In the late 19th century, Radam marketed a "Microbe Killer" that was actually a dilute and dangerous solution of sulfuric acid. 
  • (1741–1799): He invented the "Perkins' Tractors," metal rods he claimed could draw disease out of the body through a process called "tractoration". 
  • A promoter of chromotherapy (color therapy), claiming that specific colors could cure all diseases. 
  • Known for his psychic readings and claims about various health-related remedies, as well as "astral projections" and "mystic healing". 

 


08/31/25 06:51 AM #18411    

 

Jack Mallory

After posting my last about the Trump-Kennedy school of scientific quackery, I encountered this resignation letter from the Director of the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases. It is long and detailed, but intelligent, informed, and eloquent. Brought to my attention by our own (Doctor) Jennifer Harting, and worth reading not so much for your own health but that of your children and grandchildren. 

Dear Dr. Houry,

I am writing to formally resign from my position as Director of the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), effective August 28, 2025, close of business.   I am happy to stay on for two weeks to provide transition, if requested.

This decision has not come easily, as I deeply value the work that the CDC does in safeguarding public health and am proud of my contributions to that critical mission. However, after much contemplation and reflection on recent developments and perspectives brought to light by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., I find that the views he and his staff have shared challenge my ability to continue in my current role at the agency and in the service of the health of the American people. Enough is enough.

While I hold immense respect for the institution and my colleagues, I believe that it is imperative to align my professional responsibilities to my system of ethics and my understanding of the science of infectious disease, immunology, and my promise to serve the American people.  This step is necessary to ensure that I can contribute effectively in a capacity that allows me to remain true to my principles.

I am unable to serve in an environment that treats CDC as a tool to generate policies and materials that do not reflect scientific reality and are designed to hurt rather than to improve the public’s health.  The recent change in the adult and children’s immunization schedule threaten the lives of the youngest Americans and pregnant people.   The data analyses that supported this decision have never been shared with CDC despite my respectful requests to HHS and other leadership.  This lack of meaningful engagement was further compounded by a “frequently asked questions” document written to support the Secretary’s directive that was circulated by HHS without input from CDC subject matter experts and that cited studies that did not support the conclusions that were attributed to these authors.  Having worked in local and national public health for years, I have never experienced such radical non-transparency, nor have I seen such unskilled manipulation of data to achieve a political end rather than the good of the American people.

It is untenable to serve in an organization that is not afforded the opportunity to discuss decisions of scientific and public health importance released under the moniker of CDC.  The lack of communication by HHS and other CDC political leadership that culminates in social media posts announcing major policy changes without prior notice demonstrate a disregard of normal communication channels and common sense.  Having to retrofit analyses and policy actions to match inadequately thought-out announcements in poorly scripted videos or page long X posts should not be how organizations responsible for the health of people should function.  Some examples include the announcement of the change in the COVID-19 recommendations for children and pregnant people, the firing of scientists from ACIP by X post and an op-ed rather than direct communication with these valuable experts, the announcement of new ACIP members by X before onboarding and vetting have completed, and the release of term of reference for an ACIP workgroup that ignored all feedback from career staff at CDC.

The recent term of reference for the COVID vaccine work group created by this ACIP puts people of dubious intent and more dubious scientific rigor in charge of recommending vaccine policy to a director hamstrung and sidelined by an authoritarian leader.   Their desire to please a political base will result in death and disability of vulnerable children and adults.  Their base should be the people they serve not a political voting bloc.

I have always been first to challenge scientific and public health dogma in my career and was excited by the opportunity to do so again.  I was optimistic that there would be an opportunity to brief the Secretary about key topics such as measles, avian influenza, and the highly coordinated approach to the respiratory virus season.  Such briefings would allow exchange of ideas and a shared path to support the vision of “Making America Healthy Again.”  We are seven months into the new administration, and no CDC subject matter expert from my Center has ever briefed the Secretary.  I am not sure who the Secretary is listening to, but it is quite certainly not to us.  Unvetted and conflicted outside organizations seem to be the sources HHS use over the gold standard science of CDC and other reputable sources.  At a hearing, Secretary Kennedy said that Americans should not take medical advice from him.  To the contrary, an appropriately briefed and inquisitive Secretary should be a source of health information for the people he serves. As it stands now, I must agree with him, that he should not be considered a source of accurate information.

The intentional eroding of trust in low-risk vaccines favoring natural infection and unproven remedies will bring us to a pre-vaccine era where only the strong will survive and many if not all will suffer.  I believe in nutrition and exercise.  I believe in making our food supply healthier, and I also believe in using vaccines to prevent death and disability.  Eugenics plays prominently in the rhetoric being generated and is derivative of a legacy that good medicine and science should continue to shun.

The recent shooting at CDC is not why I am resigning.  My grandfather, who I am named after, stood up to fascist forces in Greece and lost his life doing so.  I am resigning to make him and his legacy proud.   I am resigning because of the cowardice of a leader that cannot admit that HIS and his minions’ words over decades created an environment where violence like this can occur.  I reject his and his colleagues’ thoughts and prayers, and advise they direct those to people that they have not actively harmed.

For decades, I have been a trusted voice for the LGBTQ community when it comes to critical health topics.  I must also cite the recklessness of the administration in their efforts to erase transgender populations, cease critical domestic and international HIV programming, and terminate key research to support equity as part of my decision.

Public health is not merely about the health of the individual, but it is about the health of the community, the nation, the world. The nation’s health security is at risk and is in the hands of people focusing on ideological self-interest.

I want to express my heartfelt gratitude for the opportunities for growth, learning, and collaboration that I have been afforded during my time at the CDC. It has been a privilege to work alongside such dedicated professionals who are committed to improving the health and well-being of communities across the nation even when under attack from within both physically and psychologically.

Thank you once again for the support and guidance I have received from you and previous CDC leadership throughout my tenure. I wish the CDC continued success in its vital mission and that HHS reverse its dangerous course to dismantle public health as a practice and as an institution.  If they continue the current path, they risk our personal well-being and the security of the United States.

Sincerely,

Demetre C. Daskalakis MD MPH (he/his/him)


08/31/25 11:53 AM #18412    

 

Jay Shackford

Good letter, Jack.


08/31/25 08:51 PM #18413    

 

Joanie Bender (Grosfeld)

Nori, www.factcheck.org is the most reilable group with the highest rating of being unbiased and they will explain to you how many lies Trump is telling the American people. Here are some examples...

https://www.factcheck.org/person/donald-trump/page/2/

You are falling for Trump saying he is grabbing up the worst criminal immigrants off the street. So many of the people that ICE arrests are hard working immigrants who are contributing to our society. The biggest crimes are committed by Americans not immigrants. Its so horrific how they are treated..separated from their families and thrown in prisons where they throw away the key. Look at how they are hounding Kilmar Abrego Garcia who came as a 16 year old to escape the gangs of El Salvador.. The Administration admitted it was a mistake to deport him but now are trying to save face by going after him with a vengeance. He has no due process to fight the charges. Trump is dismantling agencies that help us like the Environmental Protection agency and taking away restrictions on pollution.. Your grandchildren need to breath clean air too. He is getting rid of people who disagree with him. That is the way a dictatorship functions. He fired Mrs. Cook who is on the Federal Reserve and he has no right to do that. I pray the courts will say its an illegal firiing. He put in broad scale tarrifs to all the countries and that is illegal. The court said its up to Congress regarding the power of the purse. Those tarrifs are a tax on us Americans, don't fool yourself. He is doing away with diversity and installing people who agree with that. He is attacking the beautiful amazing Museum of African American History. He doesn't want their history told because they suffered and struggled and to this day they are still strugging for equality....he is allowing only the White Afrikaners to come to America and on and on and on. "The sooner he is out of office the better. The damage he is doing is far reaching and tragic. Love, Joanie


09/01/25 09:12 AM #18414    

 

Jack Mallory

My brain goes strange places in that period between becoming more or less awake and actually getting up. 

If I were to be first on the scene at a high speed traffic accident and discovered an injured Rudy Giuliani, what would I do? What is the moral best thing to do? Save Rudy? Decide the world would be a better place without him?

Moral conundrum. Can’t just let him die . . .. 

BUT! I can render first aid to the other injured first, at length, in detail, making sure they’re comfortable, helping them contact family, asking about how their day's been going, telling them jokes to help them relax, exchanging recipes, taking any injured dogs in the car to the veterinarian . . . 

Oh! And how are you, Mr. Giuliani? Mr Giuliani . . . ?


09/01/25 01:03 PM #18415    

 

Nora Skinker (Morton)

Oh my goodness.  All that puking.  You ok, Jay?  Vitriol for Christian women is not becoming but if I WERE wealthy, pretty, had never worked a day of my life,  perhaps I would know what the heck you are talking about.  Meanwhile, maybe you can explain how those attributes would create a person who is worthy of such bitter hatred. Please feel free to expound.

Joanie, of course more crimes are committed by citizens than illegal immigrants.  Did I ever suggest otherwise?  Are you quite sure that Garcia has not had due process?  Having been served deportation papers several years ago is not sufficient? I was under the impression that ICE deported him to the wrong place..El Salvador.. but brought him back to the US to be deported elsewhere.  Now the court system should/will hopefully figure it out. 

Giuliani created a safe haven in NYC for my many years of exploring the buroughs, visitng friends at Columbia U and Greenwich Village,  taking in Broadway shows and so much more.  Such safe and happy memories. Thank you, Mayor.

 

 


09/01/25 02:40 PM #18416    

 

Joanie Bender (Grosfeld)

Nori, please carefully read this to find ouit the truth about how Kilmar Abrego Garcia is being unfairly targeted by the Trump Administration and has not had due process. This link is from the most unbiased organization with high accolades called Factcheck.org...Its horrific how Abrego is treated without due process. By the way Nori, Abrego wasn't deported a few years ago.  He came to the US at 16 fleeing the gangs of El Salvador because he didn't want to be in the gangs..The Trump Administration cares nothing about the true facts. They are willing to treat someone who didn't have due process to defend himself like a brutal criminal so first they threw Abrego into the worst prison in El Salvador. The one where they torture, etc. Then when he got orders to be returned they got testimony from criminals about him which would be suspect and wanted to send him to Uganda. He hasn't had a trial about those allegations. A judge has stopped them from sending Abrego to Uganda...Trump is not interested in Abergo having any rights. .Love, Joanie

 

https://www.factcheck.org/2025/04/due-process-and-the-abrego-garcia-case/


09/01/25 02:48 PM #18417    

 

Stephen Hatchett

Jack, Jennifer, Thanks for forwarding along that letter. I'm passing it along myself. The world needs to know two things: The Trump/kennedy derangement will lead to devastating consequences for generations to come.  AND there are still courageous leaders trying to abate this storm.

Jennifer, I do wish we'd hear from you.  Right now I can only imagine your fury.  And the fury of so many others like you who have dedicated their lives and careers to battling illness.

 


09/01/25 03:41 PM #18418    

 

Nora Skinker (Morton)

Joanie, I never said Garcia was deported years ago.  I said I thought he had been served deportation papers years ago, meaning a judge had given him due process by recommending deportation to any country with the exception of El Salvador.  I believe It is also maintained that he is (or was) a wife beater and a gang member. If those accusations are found to be true, please answer as to why you would want him to remain here?  Where this politcal football will wind up will be determined in court. I have absolutely no dog in this fight.  Nor do I know enough about this abhorant health situation of which Stephen refers. So far, it has the markings of yet another political football, still to be determined. Generally, when a president gains office, he jockeys to find people around him who can further his agenda, agree somewhat with his positions.  I do believe that, perhaps because the Democratic Party seems to have no key leadership, platform or clear agenda, much from them is politcally driven only to undermine Trump.  That keeps many of us suspicious of key agencies and entities including Health, Intelligence, the Judiciary, the media, Congressional representatives, etal. JMO


09/01/25 06:01 PM #18419    

 

Jack Mallory

I'm glad Giuliani made Nori's Broadway show visits safe. The lying SOS (see federal jury decisions, $148 million damage and punitive judgements) made life considerably less pleasant and far more dangerous for the two African American Georgia election workers he repeatedly defamed.  Not perhaps as privileged as Nori. I'll take the dog to the vet before I get around to Rudy. 

Jennifer doesn't read our posts here, Stephen, but I'll pass your thanks on to her. That letter provides a wealth of information on the national health situation of which Nori claims ignorance; reading it would have addressed some of that ignorance.

Similarly, this editorial also addresses national health issues, and would remedy much ignorance, specifically of the abhorant (sic) health situation of which Nori pleads ignorance. Its seven authors, physicians and scientists, CDC directors for every president, Democrat and Republican, from Jimmy Carter to Donald Trump, address America's health security under the Trump/Kennedy derangement, as Stephen refers to it. They have very serious concerns for science, truth, and health in our country. I'd be curious to hear Nori's response to their concerns, and/or contradictory evidence she might offer from similarly credible sources. 

We Ran the C.D.C.: Kennedy Is Endangering Every American’s Health

Dr. William Foege served as director of the C.D.C. from 1977 to 1983. Dr. William Roper served as director of the C.D.C. from 1990 to 1993. Dr. David Satcher served as director of the C.D.C. from 1993 to 1998. Dr. Jeffrey Koplan served as director of the C.D.C. from 1998 to 2002. Dr. Richard Besser served as acting director of the C.D.C. in 2009. Dr. Tom Frieden served as director of the C.D.C. from 2009 to 2017. Dr. Anne Schuchat served as acting director of the C.D.C. in 2017 and 2018. Dr. Rochelle Walensky served as director of the C.D.C. from 2021 to 2023. Dr. Mandy Cohen served as director of the C.D.C. from 2023 to 2025.

 

We have each had the honor and privilege of serving as director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, either in a permanent or an acting capacity, dating back to 1977. Collectively, we spent more than 100 years working at the C.D.C., the world’s pre-eminent public health agency. We served under multiple Republican and Democratic administrations — every president from Jimmy Carter to Donald Trump — alongside thousands of dedicated staff members who shared our commitment to saving lives and improving health.

What the health and human services secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., has done to the C.D.C. and to our nation’s public health system over the past several months — culminating in his decision to fire Dr. Susan Monarez as C.D.C. director days ago — is unlike anything we had ever seen at the agency and unlike anything our country had ever experienced.

Mr. Kennedy has fired thousands of federal health workers and severely weakened programs designed to protect Americans from cancer, heart attacks, strokes, lead poisoning, injury, violence and more. Amid the largest measles outbreak in the United States in a generation, he’s focused onunproven treatments while downplaying vaccines. He canceled investments in promising medical research that will leave us ill prepared for future health emergencies. He replaced experts on federal health advisory committees with unqualified individuals who share his dangerous and unscientific views. He announced the end of U.S. support for global vaccination programs that protect millions of children and keep Americans safe, citing flawed research and making inaccurate statements. And he championed federal legislation that will cause millions of people with health insurance through Medicaid to lose their coverage. Firing Dr. Monarez — which led to the resignations of top C.D.C. officials — adds considerable fuel to this raging fire.

We are worried about the wide-ranging impact that all these decisions will have on America's health security. Residents of rural communities and people with disabilities will have even more limited access to health care. Families with low incomes who rely most heavily on community health clinics and support from state and local health departments will have fewer resources available to them. Children risk losing access to lifesaving vaccines because of the cost.

This is unacceptable, and it should alarm every American, regardless of political leanings.

The C.D.C. is an agency under Health and Human Services. During our C.D.C. tenures, we did not always agree with our leaders, but they never gave us reason to doubt that they would rely on data-driven insights for our protection or that they would support public health workers. We need only look to Operation Warp Speed during the first Trump administration — which produced highly effective and safe vaccines that saved millions of lives during the Covid-19 pandemic — as a shining example of what Health and Human Services can accomplish when health and science are at the forefront of its mission.

The current department leadership, however, operates under a very different set of rules. When Mr. Kennedy administered the oath of office to Dr. Monarez on July 31, he called her “a public health expert with unimpeachable scientific credentials.” But when she refused weeks later to rubber-stamp his dangerous and unfounded vaccine recommendations or heed his demand to fire senior C.D.C. staff members, he decided she was expendable.

These are not typical requests from a health secretary to a C.D.C. director. Not even close. None of us would have agreed to the secretary’s demands, and we applaud Dr. Monarez for standing up for the agency and the health of our communities.

When the C.D.C. was created in 1946, the average life expectancy in the United States was around 66 years. Today it is more than 78 years. While medical advances have helped, it is public health that has played the biggest role in improving both the length and the quality of life in our nation. The C.D.C. has led efforts to eradicate smallpox, increase access to lifesaving vaccinations and significantly reduce smoking rates. The agency is also on the front lines in communities across the country, delivering crucial but often less visible wins — such as containing an outbreak of H.I.V. cases in Scott County, Ind., and protectingresidents in East Palestine, Ohio, from toxic chemical exposure.

The C.D.C. is not perfect. What institution is? But over its history, regardless of which party has controlled the White House or Congress, the agency has not wavered from its mission. To those on the C.D.C. staff who continue to perform their jobs heroically in the face of the excruciating circumstances, we offer our sincere thanks and appreciation. Their ongoing dedication is a model for all of us. But it’s clear that the agency is hurting badly. The loss of Dr. Monarez and other top leaders will make it far more difficult for the C.D.C. to do what it has done for about 80 years: work around the clock to protect Americans from threats to their lives and health.

We have a message for the rest of the nation as well. This is a time to rally to protect the health of every American. Congress must exercise its oversight authority over Health and Human Services. State and local governments must fill funding gaps where they can. Philanthropy and the private sector must step up their community investments. Medical groups must continue to stand up for science and truth. Physicians must continue to support their patients with sound guidance and empathy.

And each of us must do what public health does best: look out for one another.

The men and women who have joined the C.D.C. across generations have done so not for prestige or power but because they believe deeply in the call to service. They deserve a health and human services secretary who stands up for health, supports science and has their back. So, too, does our country.

 


 


09/02/25 08:53 AM #18420    

 

Jack Mallory

I often have to remind myself to focus on Hugh Thompson, not Rusty Calley. Now I can tell myself to think about Bajun Mavalwalla, not Donald Trump. “Channel your inner Gandhi,” his veteran mom told him! And his dad's a vet, and his girlfriend's a vet, and Gandhi was his great-grandmother's godfather! How cool is all that?!

No paywall. Just click on the link. The kind of news that can brighten your day. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/sep/02/fbi-arrest-us-army-veteran-ice-protest
 


go to top 
  Post Message
  
    Prior Page
 Page  
Next Page